Potent Quotables (updated periodically)

  • "If you like sausages and laws, you should never watch either one of them being made." -- Otto von Bismarck
  • "God who gave us life, gave us liberty. Can the liberties of a nation be secure when we have removed a conviction that these liberties are the gift of God? Indeed I tremble for my country when I reflect that God is just, that his justice cannot sleep forever." -- Thomas Jefferson
  • "The best way to prove a stick is crooked is to lay a straight one beside it" -- FW Boreham
  • "There are two kinds of people in the world. Those who walk into a room and say, 'There you are' and those who say, 'Here I am'" -- Abigail Van Buren
  • "It was not political rhetoric, mass rallies or poses of moral indignation that gave the people a better life. It was capitalism." -- Thomas Sowell

Tuesday, September 08, 2009

The Importance of Being

I've written before about the importance of understanding the other side's arguments. Here is libertarian economist Tyler Cowen's attempt to describe modern conservatism. I happen to disagree with his point #4, which I think he has backwards. Strong family structures are the most important domestic issue, from which follows a strong educational underpinning. Tyler is talking about school-based education, which, to me, is only a part of a child's educational experience.
The most thought-provoking point:
10. Responsibility is a more important value than either liberty or equality.
I believe (individual) responsibility both leads to and follows from liberty. And as I have said before, conservatives believe in equality of opportunity, not equality of results. It is difficult for me to separate those three values and assign priority to one or the other, but I think he probably has the order correct.

This is a follow-up to his previous attempt to define progressivism.

See also this follow-up post:
Consider the way our views normally evolve. We sort of hunker down in our ideological bunkers trying to fend off various attacks and challenges. Sometimes an especially forceful argument will require a modification in the fortifications—and on rare occasions, we’ll even be forced to abandon a position. Which is to say, we learn from other perspectives largely in a defensive mode, through a kind of Darwinian selection of arguments. But what if instead we tried to use the insights available from our own perspectives, not to defeat or convert the other guy, but to give his argument its best form? This might sound like giving aid and comfort to the enemy, but even in terms of the Darwinian struggle, there’s value to being able to show how your view trumps even the optimal form of the competition.
Typically, when we’re not at battle stations, we recognize that the other guy’s values are genuine values; we just give priority to different ones.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Comment here or write us at GrimpHQ@gmail.com